Short Par 4 Reviews in 2024 [Finest Golf Box]

Short Par 4 is a golf-focused monthly subscription box service that delivers premium apparel, equipment, and accessories to members’ doorsteps. Founded in 2014, Short Par 4 aims to outfit golfers in style while providing value and convenience.

This in-depth Short Par 4 review covers the company background, membership tiers and pricing, style preferences, box contents and brands, membership perks, pros and cons, and overall value based on real customer experiences.

2 golfers unboxing clothes from short par 4

Company Background.

Short Par 4 was founded in 2014 by Bobby Dimeo, a graduate of the Golf Academy of America. The company saw a gap in the market for a subscription service that caters specifically to golf enthusiasts through curated deliveries of apparel and equipment.

The golf subscription box market has grown rapidly, as evidenced by Short Par 4’s own success and competitors like Mullybox, Bogey Box, Par Pak, Major League Crate and more. While most services focus on equipment or training aids, Short Par 4 differentiates itself by specializing in golf apparel and accessories.

Short Par 4’s mission is to bring quality and style to golfers in a convenient way. The company takes the hassle out of shopping while offering members-only discounts. The company leverages its large subscriber base to get brand deals and bulk order the latest gear each season.

Membership Levels

Short Par 4 offers three main membership tiers:

  • Fairway – $54.95/month The Fairway tier is the most popular among subscribers and offers solid value. Approximately 2-3 premium items are included such as shirts, pants, hats, balls, gloves, etc. Brands are more mainstream like Callaway, Oakley, Under Armour and Puma. Total retail value is typically $100+.
  • Executive – $109.95/month Geared toward upscale style and brands, the Executive tier delivers premium labels like Greyson, Travis Mathew, and Johnnie-O. While pricier, the focus is on quality and exclusivity over value. Expect at least 1-2 high-end pieces.
  • Magnolia – $99/month Short Par 4 also introduced a Magnolia tier for female golfers. Gift cards are also available if you’d prefer the recipient to choose their own preferences.

Style Preferences

Members take a style profile quiz to select their fashion preferences before receiving their first box:

  1. Traditional – conservative staples, subdued classics inspired by legends like Phil Mickelson and Fred Couples.
  2. Loud & Wild – bold, vibrant designs and patterns inspired by PGA pros Rickie Fowler and Ian Poulter.
  3. Athletic – casual, athletic looks popular with younger golfers. Think Dustin Johnson and Rory McIlroy.

All Styles – For variety, get a mix of all preferences. The perfect introduction to the short par 4 experience.

The ability to customize preferences makes the subscription significantly more personalized than some competitors. Members receive items tailored to their tastes each month.

man with golf club with gloves from short par 4

Box Contents & Brands

True to its name, the vast majority of items included in Short Par 4 boxes are apparel and accessories to outfit you on the course. Expect products like:

  • Shirts – Polos, Button-Downs, Sweaters, Outerwear
  • Pants – golf pants, chinos, shorts
  • Golf Hats
  • Golf Gloves
  • Sunglasses
  • Socks and Underwear
  • Golf Balls
  • Accessories – club covers, ball markers, divot tools

As promised, the labels feature major golf brands such as Nike, Adidas, Under Armour, Ralph Lauren and more. Short Par 4 also includes premium labels like Greyson, ORIGINAL PENGUIN Golf, and Travis Mathew that aren’t as readily available.

Packages also sometimes include bonus lifestyle items such as wine coupons, snacks, and electronics. Special tournament packages include exclusive player-edition gear.

While not a focus, subscribers have occasionally received clubs, rangefinders, bags, and other equipment. But the majority of items each month are apparel and accessories to enhance your golf wardrobe and improve your playing experience.

Membership Perks

In addition to discounted prices and customized deliveries, Short Par 4 members can take advantage of perks such as

  • SP4 Rewards Bucks – Earn Rewards Bucks with purchases that can be applied to future boxes or items in the Vault. Higher tiers earn rewards faster.
  • VIP Treatment (Executive) – Concierge service, expedited shipping, other upgrades
  • Free Returns (Executive & Tour) – $10 fee for Fairway
  • Replacement of lost/damaged boxes
  • Convenient billing & free shipping
  • Ability to skip months or pause your membership
  • Access to members-only offers and limited quantities

Overall, Short Par 4 focuses on premium value, convenience and exclusivity. Members have access to special treatment and flexible membership policies that many competitors lack.

golfers playing golf

The Pros

Based on aggregated Short Par 4 reviews and unboxings, here are some of the biggest pros of the subscription service:

  • Substantial Retail Value – Most members feel they get double the price they paid or more in real savings off regular prices. This makes the membership “worth it” every month.
  • Easy and Convenient – Curation of top golf apparel makes it easy to select items. Delivered right to your door in premium packaging.
  • Must-have golf brands – All the major labels like Nike, Adidas, Under Armour, Oakley. Also more boutique names like Thomas Cook that are harder to find.
  • Latest styles – Pieces selected each season, not outdated inventory. New cool gear every month.
  • Customization – Style quiz allows you to select designs that match your preferences from conservative to bold.
  • Quality & Detail – Well-made premium apparel that looks and feels high-end. Beautifully crafted accessories.
  • Easy returns/exchanges – Members can return most items for a refund or credit if something doesn’t work.
  • Fun experience – It’s exciting for avid golfers to receive a monthly “gift” box full of new gear to try out.

The consensus is that Short Par 4 takes the hassle out of shopping while delivering excellent value, quality and style. It stands out from the competition with its premium brands, high retail value, and personalized experience.

Golfer has tumbs up

The Cons

While most reviews are positive, here are some areas of concern noted by Short Par 4 members:

  • Quality Control Issues – Some complaints of torn seams, loose threads, and other defects in items received.
  • Sizing issues – Incorrect fit can be a nuisance, especially with shirts and pants. Return/exchange less than ideal.
  • Higher price points – Executive and Tour packages get expensive for some. But the value is still there.
  • Occasional duds – Inevitably some items will be missed based on individual preferences.
  • Lack of customization – Can’t hand-pick exact products other than style profile. The element of surprise can lead to disappointment.
  • Delayed shipping – Especially during COVID-19, some orders arrived late despite communication.
  • Limited selection – Mostly big brands. Some would like to see more niche, higher-end labels.

While most Short Par 4 reviews are overwhelmingly positive, there are some drawbacks, mostly related to quality control, sizing accuracy, and customization. This seems to be common with most subscription box services that mass-produce orders. However, their excellent customer service helps address any issues quickly.


When it comes to value, Short Par 4 delivers on its promise of “2x retail value.” Actual dollar amounts vary by membership tier, but most subscribers feel they consistently get twice their money’s worth:

  • Fairway Tier – Estimated $100+ retail value per shipment based on content. At $54.95/month, most feel this is a solid value.
  • Executive Tier – Estimates of $150-$200 per box are common. Given the $109.95 price, this is another great value option.
  • Magnolia Tier – As a newer offering, retail value is harder to estimate, but is expected to be substantial for the $99/month price.
  • Tour Experience – As a premium curated offering, retail value is harder to estimate, but tends to be substantial. Signed memorabilia also adds value. At $125/month, it is likely to be worthwhile for fans of a particular professional player.

While it varies from month to month, the membership tiers correctly set expectations for the value provided. Short Par 4 has delivered on producing savings for members, according to reviews.

Giving Short Par 4 as a gift also allows the recipient to use the credit toward products they actually want. Overall, it provides a level of service, brand, and flexibility that validates the membership price tiers.

The bottom line

Short Par 4 has earned its reputation as one of the leading golf subscription boxes on the market. It has carved out a niche by focusing specifically on apparel and accessories rather than equipment or training aids.

The Short Par 4 model succeeds by combining premium golf brands, significant retail savings, and a personalized experience tailored to members’ tastes. Regular golfers can conveniently change their wardrobe every month with the latest styles.

While there have been some quality and sizing issues, their great customer service addresses issues promptly. Overall, for most members, the surprise and enjoyment of the short par 4 boxes seems to outweigh any shortcomings.

If building your golf wardrobe with major brands in stylish fits sounds appealing, Short Par 4 is probably a good fit for you. Membership levels offer flexibility depending on your budget and desired level of exclusivity.

In summary, for any avid golfer or lifestyle fan, Short Par 4 is definitely worth a try, especially with the $25 off welcome offer. The discounted prices, prestigious brands, personalized style and overall enjoyment will have you looking forward to new arrivals at your doorstep every month during the golf season.

How often do you ship?

Boxes are shipped monthly. You can also pause or skip months as needed.

What if I don’t like an item?

You can return most items within 30 days for a refund, credit, or exchange. Shipping charges may apply.

Can I exchange an item if it is the wrong size?

Yes, Short Par 4 allows exchanges for different sizes. Return shipping fees may apply for lower levels.

How long does shipping take?

Orders ship within 2 business days and usually arrive within 5-7 days in the U.S. International shipping times vary.

What happens if a box is lost or damaged?

Contact your customer service team and they will replace damaged boxes. Insurance is included.

How do I cancel or pause my subscription?

You can skip months, pause your subscription, or cancel at any time online or by emailing [email protected].

What happens if a box is lost or damaged?

Contact your customer service team and they will replace damaged boxes. Insurance is included.

How do I cancel or pause my subscription?

You can skip months, pause your subscription, or cancel at any time online or by emailing [email protected].

Can I purchase past box items individually?

Yes, the Vault Store has back box items that you can purchase individually or with Reward Credits.

What forms of payment do you accept?

Short Par 4 accepts all major credit cards, PayPal and Amazon Pay.